Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Faith, Works or both? Grace, Righteousness or both?

Can there be a realization of the existence of God unless there is a society? I am convinced it is not possible. In the absence of a society, what world would it be to save which God would send his only begotten son? John 3:16. Even God cannot be a loner. Who will He show concern for?

Not too long ago, I was before a prayer group to speak on "concern for others". There was no specific brief on what I was supposed to speak on. However, I was told I must keep my talk confined to "spiritual aspects" giving only sparingly examples from everyday life. A rather self-defeating fiat, I thought.

Trying to stick to "spiritual aspects", I started by observing that one of the definitions of Spirituality (we could say) is ‘going beyond oneself’ – the ‘ability to go beyond oneself’.

"Spirituality, you will agree, is a qualitative dimension. But even when God judges, he would need some concrete and quantitative measures to judge. Do you agree?" I asked. The group of about 50 people were silent. They then slowly nodded in agreement. I used Mathew 25:31-46 to 'substantiate' my point.

Next, I gave a theological enunciation using Karl Rahner's idea of "Economic Trinity". "We see that even in one God, there are three persons – the most Holy Trinity. In themselves, they form a community." The group nodded again.

Karl Rahner, one of the greatest theologians of our times, a Jesuit and a professor of our dear Pope John Paul II talks about ‘Economic Trinity’ and the ‘Immanent Trinity’. We know the Father, Son and the Holy Spirit by the roles they perform. The Father decrees the Son to be incarnated to save mankind, the Son is born and dies to redeem the world and the Holy Spirit is a ‘grace dispenser’.

Karl Rahner said that the roles performed by each person in the Trinity are not appropriated to the respective person. Jesus, the son of God becomes man cannot be considered in isolation of the Father’s love. There cannot be an experience of the Holy Spirit without the experience of Jesus and the Father’s love. As we become aware of the role of each person of the Trinity, we become aware of the inner life of God. We note that the three different persons are not 3 different consciousnesses. They are One Consciousness and yet a Community. That’s what we call Immanent Trinity: the mysterious existence together of the three divine persons in their eternal life, or God’s life in se.

We also note – in the context of the topic – that each of the roles in the Trinity presupposes man as the recipient of God’s grace. John 3:16! And from this we know grace is not extrinsic to nature but is none other than the indwelling of the triune God in the human soul, a bestowal of God Himself.

Sum it: God in 3 persons are one in the other – one consciousness though different roles. One role cannot be aloof from the other. These roles reveal the inner life of God. They are a self-communication of grace to man. It is up to us whether or not we respond to this self-communication.

God’s Spirit is in my heart. / He has called me and set me apart. /
This is what I have to do – what I have to do.
He sent me to give the good news to the poor. / Tell prisoners that they are prisoners no more.
Tell blind people that they can see. / And set the downtrodden free.
Giving several examples, I sought to draw the group to think, "What use is spirituality and religion if it does not extend for the common good?"
Nothing we do in isolation can remain from affecting the society we live in. Global warming, extinction of species, pollution, war, inflation and dirty public toilets are all results of lack of concern for others.
  • I am not going to be back here, so why should I keep it clean?
  • We live in an area with good water supply, so why run to conserve water?
  • I can afford this product. So why wonder if I really need it?
  • Why should I teach my colleague what I know? No-one taught me when I was new. Besides, my value in this company will diminish.
  • The taxi’s waiting? So what? My friends paying for it.
  • ADD YOUR OWN POINTS.
To Christians, nothing added to this list is out-of-syllabus. The Church teaches extensively on every aspect that affects society. It is called the Social Teaching of the Church. It consists of Seven Key Themes:
  • Sanctity of human life and dignity of the person
  • Call to family, community, and participation
  • Rights and responsibilities [incl. PROPERTY]
  • Preferential Option for the poor and vulnerable
  • Dignity of work and the rights of workers
  • Solidarity
  • Care for God's creation
A good part of the Book of Ezekiel seems to show God as a cruel tormentor. But as one commentator put it, “how to speak of love without mentioning jealousy and violence?” God is upset that His Bride has shamelessly gone after the pleasures of the world. So he goes and brings her back by force from her lovers. ‘Lovers’ meaning the things of the world – property, career, glamour and the like. We read that the Temple of Jerusalem is destroyed. Ezekiel along with his people is on an exile and echoes God’s angst over losing His people. The temple of Jerusalem is destroyed and people are exiled to Babylon. Ezekiel keeps echoing God’s angst over the loss of His people – a fact actually showing God went with his people on the exile. He had no business anymore in the temple.


In a sense, even God goes beyond His boundaries.

The spirituality of showing concern for others cannot be a standalone. Spirituality is the driver. We have toyed with the known for long. It is time to tread on the unknown – outside our boundaries. Take the Gift of Tongues: Isn’t it departing from the known and making a ground-breaking entry into the supernatural spiritual realm?

What then stops us from transcending differences of language, religion, caste, gender, ethnicity and every other difference?

How will I pay bills? How will I manage the loans? My health is important. My career is important. If these are our only concerns, Chapter 7 of Ezekiel where God spells disaster on Israel for going her own way. But what God has in store for a nation that turns to Him, we note when we turn to Chapter 47 (towards the end of the book), through Ezekiel’s visions for the salvation of his people.

In many ways, my talk drew flak among some stalwart members of the prayer group who believed that ‘good works’ were the subject matter of ‘stewardship’. Also, they mistook that grace was sufficient for our salvation and “good works” do not matter at all. Strangely, they missed the exhortation that good works must be an outcome of our faith.

‘Justification by faith alone’ or ‘sola fide’ was Martin Luther’s doctrine which divided Catholics and Lutherans. Luther taught that “God's pardon for guilty sinners is granted to and received through faith or belief alone, to the exclusion of all human efforts or works.” Catholicism however holds that grace, which implies good works, is also necessary for salvation (Matthew 25:31-46); that is, by God's grace through faith (also a favour given by him, Matthew 16:17) (Ephesians 2:8-10), and the Christian's response to it in God's grace (Galatians 5:6), as faith perfected by good works, (James 2:22). It may be interesting to note here that Martin Luther pooh-poohed the Letter of James as a ‘Gospel of Straw’ because it stood in the way of his famous doctrine!!

Catholicism gives a lot of importance to the common good as part of God’s expectation of justice and peace among His people. In the book ‘Relevant No More’ by Mark D. Brewer, he quotes Rembert G. Weakland, Archbishop of Milwaukee on the subject: "Self-interest cannot stand alone in Catholic thought. It cannot be dissociated from love of God and love of neighbour. In fact, love of neighbour becomes the first criterion for love of God. In this perspective, cooperation becomes as strong a motive as competition." The Catholic worldview places a heavy emphasis on concern for others.” This is quite contrary to the Protestant Ethic which produces a more individualistic worldview.

Heartening that lately, both Catholics and Protestants/Evangelicals have taken great strides to bridge the divide. For instance, there is a return to faith-building among Catholics and Protestants are seen to extend themselves through socially relevant ministries.

Let me leave you with this piece of news from Zenit for further study on what my ramblings are all about. ‘Pope Notes Anniversary of Justification Document’ at http://www.zenit.org/article-27423?l=english . This is about a document signed by John Paul II and the Lutherans in 1999 stating a common understanding on the issue.

"By grace alone, in faith in Christ's saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good works."


I am sure, for many of us with renewed personal knowledge of Jesus and Paul’s teachings regarding justification by faith, it will be a good idea to study document. You can find it at http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html

Tailpiece: It is my personal opinion about the Charismatic Renewal Services that great care is taken in faith formation, exercise of glossolalia, the Word of God and the Sacraments. There are ministries (intercession, mobilization, music, audio-visual….) ‘working’ for these purposes through the seminars, retreats, sleepless nights, work from office, work using office resources and such other formats – event after event, month after month and year after year. Good! Many have benefitted – I included.

But in the bargain, personal prayer and example silently suffer. Witnessing takes a blatant beating. The body temple is demolished. The very object of the teachings is suffocated in the frenzy of delivering the calendared event.

After a particular event, the organizers were quizzing trusty participants and other helpers whether they heard what was said by a certain leader who led the Inner Healing service. Reportedly, the leaders used some explicit language that didn’t go down well with some young participants.

Organizers have become event-dispensers and are no longer willing recipients of the spiritual richness they seek to introduce the souls to. Haven’t we always seen at least some idle members of the organizing team sit a tad away from the rest of the flock in the events they organize – clearly drawing a line between the purported (?) spiritual haves and have-nots? That holier-than-thou attitude?!

Are our hearts really renewed while we are being called to good works? Or is it all some kind of assembly line - I meet Jesus; then I introduce Jesus to you; next the three of us find more to introduce Jesus to.

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Wretched man that I am!!


The journey that every saint has walked and is walking consist of an interesting spiritual phenomenon. You and I have been experiencing it almost everyday.


After every prayer hour, Eucharistic celebration, confession or any events causing 'to-change' desires, I have quite often ended up with frustration and serious stress. The very simple reason ; I was not able to stick to my resolutions.

It varies from; not being gentle to my family members - be disciplined - becoming holy.

Every efforts predominantly results in vain. Though I believe, falling Nth time is an opportunity to rise for the Nth time, the inability to progress spiritually deceives me to a larger spiritual damage. I tend to lose hope in God's mercy and grace.


But however Our Father is mighty in His rescue and merciful in His plan for us. As I wondered why I keep repeating the very same principal acts against God's love, through prayer and contemplation, He brought me to a realization that 'self-reliance' causes more spiritual damage than sin.


"St.Teresa of Avila testifies: 'This self-reliance was what destroyed me.' Extract from The Fulfillment of all desire - Teresa points out the discernible difference between the demeanour of someone who is approaching the spiritual journey as a matter of one's own effort, and that of someone approaching it as a matter of trusting in the mercy of God."


I was walking with Christ, but slowly started walking over Him!!! :-(

Thanks be to God and praise Him for His mercy!! ;-) He brought me back to the right track.


He did not stop with that!!! He understands me so well that He found a lovely method to reveal to me the struggle that is happening within me. How sweet of you Jesus - you teach me in the way I most enjoy!!


And dear friend, today I share and explain with you, the very process of struggle that we undergo in our life. Let's start by playing a game now.


Things to play: a stop watch, a scribbling pad and a pen/pencil - That’s it!! We are all set to play this game!!


You will find below a picture with set of words.


Round 1: Read the words loud and clear - repeat the same exercise and now time it. Now try to record the best timing you can read the entire list of words loud and clear. (I had played this game with different people and the record breaking time is 6.8 seconds)





Round 2: Now you will NOT read the word but say the colour, loud and clear (The colour in which the words are written). Repeat the exercise and record your best time. Try to do your best and observe yourself.


Do not read further until you have finished with round 1 & 2 directives!!!



99.99999% of chances you tried, your round 2 timing would be too far compared to your Round 1 timing.


Why is it so ? There is no change to any of the elements of the picture, but still you struggle to say the colour. You rush to read the word rather than say the colour. Aren't you sure that you need to say the colour and not read the word ?? Then why is it you are so impulsive and tend to read the word ??


Why ? What is happening to me ? Why do I read when I wanted to say?

The reason is;

YOUR RIGHT BRAIN TRIES TO SAY THE COLOUR BUT YOUR LEFT BRAIN INSISTS ON READING THE WORD.


If you are completely aware of what's happening within you during Round 2, you will observe that though you wanted to recognize and say the colour with your right brain, your left brain overrides every command unless and until you thrust it down your neural network. This is called the Left Brain - Right Brain Conflict.


This is due to the simple reason we are habituated to read letters rather than recognize the colour they are written in. Is this the fault of the brain or the eyes ?? Neither of them - by practice we can definitely better our Round 2 timing.


Isn't this thrilling and surprising ?? But in what way does it relate to our spiritual struggle??


"What no eye has seen , nor ear heard, nor the human heart conceived, what God has prepared for those who love him". These things God has revealed to us through the Spirit; - 1 Cor 2:9-10


Most of our spiritual struggles are nothing but the product of similar conflict between our flesh & mind. Read Romans 7: 14 -15, 19-20, 23-25.


St. Paul very clearly explain the inner conflict between our mind and flesh. Our inner nature is sinful and being influenced to sin should not surprise nor sadden us. But rather become aware that it’s the very presence of God's grace enabling us to detect this evil nature.


This passage was the most complicated one for me to comprehend, until God revealed the truth to me through this simple experiment. Now try relating St.Paul's message to the game we played.


"For I do not say the colour that I want, but I do read the word that I do not want to" - what a revelation!!. Our simple struggle we observed in playing this game goes well with the scriptures.


The only solution is Rom 7: v24-25 - Only with the help of Lord Jesus Christ we can overcome this conflict. For we cannot fight with our flesh with our own strength - for both are same.


So please don't give up the fight, enjoy every moment of the battle. Grab the fun and run with it.
Creative Commons License
Nuts, Bolts and Youth by Loreto Xavier is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.